Effective nonprofit board governance in times of change

November 11, 2026
Principal Kerri Mast and Managing Director and Head of Philanthropic Advisory Drew Rabe discuss effective nonprofit board governance during complex and uncertain times.

Nonprofit organizations routinely navigate periods of uncertainty. Changes in community needs and funding, operating costs, market volatility, and an evolving legal and policy environment can challenge even well-established organizations.

During periods of change, effective governance requires more than responding to immediate concerns. Boards should remain focused on mission, financial sustainability, thoughtful risk oversight, and the organization’s capacity to adapt. The following strategies can help boards govern effectively during periods of change and uncertainty.

Fiscal management

Financial stewardship is a core board responsibility, and shoring up an organization’s financial position requires sound fiscal management. Boards should understand their organization’s financial position, monitor material risks, and provide strong oversight of the practices intended to support its short– and long–term financial sustainability. Many nonprofit boards have established practices intended to protect the organization in the event of an eventual downturn.

Established operating nonprofit organizations often maintain operating reserves to manage unexpected revenue shortfalls, expenses, or disruptions. The appropriate reserve level will vary based on the organization’s business model, revenue concentration, liquidity needs, and risk profile. Even organizations that have planned carefully may find that their reserves are insufficient during prolonged disruption, especially if charitable contributions and other revenue decline while demands for services increase.

Private foundations and other grantmaking organizations should align their spending, investment, and liquidity policies, which should be reviewed together with their legal obligations, charitable objectives, and intended time horizons. Perpetual institutions may have spending policies that seek to maintain purchasing power and sustainability over a long period of time and are integrated with the investment allocation. A limited–life foundation, on the other hand, may prioritize increased near–term spending. Because the annual spending level is based on historic market values, a sudden drop in asset value may result in spending levels that exceed the spending rate in a given year, further depleting assets. Private foundations may be facing portfolio losses even as they recognize great need in the community.

Both private foundations and operating nonprofits might need to consider the impact of prolonged disruption. Increasingly, sophisticated organizations find it useful to conduct stress tests, whereby they model different financial and operating scenarios to analyze the potential results over a period of time.

The results of these stress tests and related scenario planning can help boards understand how changes in revenue, expenses, investment performance, liquidity, or demand for services could affect the organization. Boards may also identify in advance the indicators that would trigger a change in spending, staffing, programming, fundraising, or investment strategy. If additional liquidity is needed, boards should evaluate available options – including expense reductions, additional fundraising, use of reserves, or borrowing such as traditional loans or bond issuance – after considering the organization’s repayment capacity, restrictions, risk tolerance, and long–term financial health.

Strategic planning and adaptive thinking

If circumstances change materially and a board has adopted a multiyear strategic plan to achieve its organization’s mission, it may need to revisit and revise the plan. Components may need to be reprioritized, giving top priority to those that are deemed essential for the operation of the organization or the delivery of essential programming in the current environment. Other parts of the plan – such as capital projects or campaigns – may need to be delayed, modified, or reconsidered.

An effective board might utilize an adaptive thinking model:

  1. Take a high–level view of the circumstances and key assumptions
  2. Consider possible solutions and their risks
  3. Select and implement the most favorable option and clarify responsibility for implementation
  4. Review the outcomes, seek feedback, and iterate as needed

The adaptive thinking model recognizes that decisions sometimes must be made with incomplete information, assumes that mistakes will be made, and embraces mistakes as a necessary part of the process to arrive at the best solution. Rather than treating every imperfect outcome as a failure, boards should test their assumptions, seek timely feedback, monitor results, and adjust promptly as new information becomes available. It is important to identify mistakes quickly in order to make changes and try out new solutions. In reviewing the outcomes and in an effort to get to the next iteration as quickly as possible, organizations should reflect on how to shorten the feedback loop. Strategies for doing so include:

  • Seeking feedback during the implementation phase instead of waiting until the end
  • Asking focused questions designed to produce actionable input for specific issues instead of general feedback
  • Creating a distinction between those who contribute feedback and those who have decision-making authority

Throughout this process, boards should remain clear about their role. The board sets direction, provides oversight, and makes decisions reserved for it, while management is generally responsible for day–to–day operations. Regular communication helps boards remain appropriately engaged without stepping into management’s role.

Collaboration and best practices

Organizations should not assume they need to develop solutions alone. Even for nonprofit organizations that have faced difficult circumstances in the past, new challenges may require a fresh approach. The need to adapt affects operating organizations and grantmaking organizations. Boards and staff may benefit from listening to constituents, consulting peer organizations and community partners, and collaborating where shared approaches could improve effectiveness or efficiency. As circumstances and evidence evolve, boards should also periodically review key policies and governance practices to make sure they remain relevant, practical, and aligned with the organization’s mission, strategy, and legal obligations.

Operating organizations may need to modify their approach as community needs and operating conditions change in order to provide programs and services to their constituents that are appropriate in the current environment. Consider, for example, an organization focused on providing outdoor skills and leadership development for youth, which includes overnight camping experiences. In the current environment, in which conversations around gender fluidity have become increasingly common, the organization might think about adjusting the ways it offers experiences. Solutions may include reconfiguring sleeping arrangements or restroom facilities, and modifying language in training, orientation, and program materials. The board’s role is to ensure that the organization remains mission-focused and responsive to the needs of those it serves, which management is generally responsible for developing and implementing appropriate program changes.

Organizations looking for solutions will recognize that they are not alone in their need to adapt and may consider collaborating with others in the development of best practices or forming task forces to do so. The board and staff of many organizations are having regular meetings with peer groups to facilitate these discussions. It is also important to recognize that established best practices may need to be refined regularly.

Grantmaking organizations may wish to adapt their spending policy or strategy to meet current needs. Consider, for example, a private foundation that is interested in solutions to affordable housing and makes grants to organizations that seek to expand the number of affordable housing units in its geographic area. Recognizing the impact of inflation on those experiencing difficulty affording their rent, the foundation may consider adapting its strategy and expanding its funding to include rental subsidies, which provide immediate relief. The foundation may consider collaborating with other grantmakers to identify effective relief programs; the foundation may also consider collaborating with its existing grantees to discuss relief-based solutions. Before changing course, the foundation should consult existing grantees and affected communities, assess where its resources can add the greatest value, and consider whether collaboration with other funders would strengthen the response. Where appropriate, multiyear or general support funding may give grantees greater capacity to plan, respond to changing conditions, and direct resources where they are needed most.

Periodic governance review

Effective boards periodically review their governance practices to make sure they continue to support the organization’s mission, strategy, and decision-making needs. As organizations evolve, boards may benefit from revisiting their governing documents, committee structures, meeting practices, board composition, succession plans, and key policies.

Establishing strong nonprofit board governance

Strong governance is especially important when conditions are uncertain, and during tumultuous times, board members often reflect on effective governance. Effective boards remain focused on mission while strengthening financial oversight, testing assumptions, listening to stakeholders, and adapting when circumstances require.

In our Philanthropic Advisory practice, we work with families, endowments, foundations, and nonprofit organizations on strategy, asset management, grantmaking, management of operating entities, fundraising, governance, and other issues that support effective and sustainable philanthropy.

If you would like to discuss any of these topics, we would welcome the conversation.

Contact Us

Up Next
Up Next

Making the most of your annual board meeting

For private foundations, the annual board meeting is an opportunity to pause, reflect, and make thoughtful decisions about the year ahead. Head of Philanthropic Advisory Drew Rabe provides an overview of what matters most when planning and leading an effective annual board meeting.

Brown Brothers Harriman & Co. (“BBH”) may be used to reference the company as a whole and/or its various subsidiaries generally. This material and any products or services may be issued or provided in multiple jurisdictions by duly authorized and regulated subsidiaries. This material is for general information and reference purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax or investment advice and is not intended as an offer to sell, or a solicitation to buy securities, services or investment products. Any reference to tax matters is not intended to be used, and may not be used, for purposes of avoiding penalties under the U.S. Internal Revenue Code, or other applicable tax regimes, or for promotion, marketing or recommendation to third parties. All information has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but accuracy is not guaranteed, and reliance should not be placed on the information presented. This material may not be reproduced, copied or transmitted, or any of the content disclosed to third parties, without the permission of BBH. All trademarks and service marks included are the property of BBH or their respective owners. © Brown Brothers Harriman & Co. 2026. All rights reserved. PB-09819-2026-08-18

As of June 15, 2022 Internet Explorer 11 is not supported by BBH.com.